Thorne vs Gnarly vs Momentous: The Ultimate Whey Protein Showdown
Share
In a market flooded with protein powders, three brands consistently rise above the noise: Thorne, Gnarly, and Momentous. Each claims elite sourcing, clean formulations, and athlete-grade performance. But which one actually delivers?
Let’s break it down—ingredient by ingredient, certification by certification, and benefit by benefit.
Brand DNA: Who They’re Built For
|
Brand |
Philosophy |
Ideal For |
|
Clinical-grade, minimalist, data-driven |
Biohackers, health professionals, precision-focused athletes |
|
|
Transparent, adventure-fueled, whole-food ethos |
Endurance athletes, climbers, outdoor lifestyle consumers |
|
|
Elite performance, military-tested, recovery-optimized |
Pro athletes, trainers, tactical operators |
Ingredient Breakdown: What’s Inside Matters
|
Feature |
Thorne Whey Isolate |
Gnarly Whey |
Momentous Whey Isolate |
|
Protein Type |
100% whey isolate |
Blend of isolate + concentrate |
100% whey isolate |
|
Source |
Grass-fed cows (New Zealand) |
Grass-fed cows (USA) |
Grass-fed cows (Ireland) |
|
Processing |
Cold-filtered |
Cold-processed |
Microfiltered |
|
Sweeteners |
Stevia |
Stevia + monk fruit |
Organic stevia |
|
Additives |
None |
None |
None |
|
Flavoring |
Natural vanilla/cocoa |
Natural flavors |
Natural flavors |
Certifications & Testing: Trust, Verified
|
Certification |
Thorne |
Gnarly |
Momentous |
|
NSF Certified for Sport® |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
|
Informed-Sport Tested |
No |
Yes |
Yes |
|
Third-Party Heavy Metal Testing |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
|
Gluten-Free |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Functional Performance: Beyond the Label
|
Feature |
Thorne |
Gnarly |
Momentous |
|
Digestive Enzymes |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
|
Lactose Content |
Very low |
Moderate |
Very low |
|
Recovery Support |
Moderate |
High |
High |
|
Mixability |
Excellent |
Good |
Excellent |
|
Taste Profile |
Clean, mild |
Rich, slightly sweet |
Smooth, neutral |
Pricing & Value
|
Brand |
Price (1 lb) |
Subscription Discount |
Free Shipping |
|
Thorne |
$65 |
10% off |
$75+ |
|
Gnarly |
$59 |
10% off |
$75+ |
|
Momentous |
$65 |
10% off |
$75+ |
Strategic Takeaways
- Choose Thorne if you want purity, precision, and clinical-grade isolate with zero fluff.
- Choose Gnarly if you value flavor, immune support, and a more whole-food approach to recovery.
- Choose Momentous if you’re optimizing for elite performance, recovery, and military-grade compliance.
Final Word
In the end, it’s not about which brand is “best”—it’s about which one aligns with your physiology, training demands, and recovery goals. Whether you're scaling a mountain, dialing in macros, or prepping for competition, your protein should work as hard as you do.